I would still choose this University. One thing to keep in mind is that Wesleyan has a very particular social atmosphere, some describe it as "weird". As such, all students should visit Wesleyan for a couple of days before deciding to attend. Otherwise, you may be in for the unpleasant surprise of finding out that you are put-off by all the diverse people at this school.
It is a wonderful place. Full of smart, passionate people. The campus is rather hilly, and it's not always the easiest place to make friends, but academically and culturally, topnotch.