Carleton College provides an incredible experience for everyone, both in and out of the classroom. It is challenging academically and offers countless extracurricular opportunities. The students, staff, and faculty all want you to succeed and be as happy as possible.
I'd still go to this college if I had to make the decision again. The psychology department is a horrifying joke, but the rest of the college is wonderful in terms of academics, and there's a vast variety of social/extracurricular activities.